Reselling

Duskmourn Commander Decks Price & eBay Resale Value

· 5 min read · By the Friends & Family team

Searches for Duskmourn Commander decks are up 80% this week. Two years after launch, one of the four decks sells for about five times what the other three do on eBay. Here is which one, and what each deck is worth now.

The four Duskmourn: House of Horror Commander deck boxes, with Endless Punishment and its Valgavoth, Harrower of Souls commander large on the left and Miracle Worker, Death Toll and Jump Scare! on the right
Image: Wizards of the Coast, via the Duskmourn: House of Horror Commander decklists page on magic.wizards.com

Duskmourn Commander decks sold for about $45 each at launch in September 2024, and on eBay this month one of them sells for about five times that: Endless Punishment, the black-red Valgavoth deck, sold sealed for $224.95 and $229.99 in mid-November 2026. The other three are far cheaper: Death Toll sold for $41.87 to $59.99 and Miracle Worker for $66.60. A sealed set of all four sold for $227.50 to $399 in November. Wizards never published a print run, so there is no rarity number; the price split between decks is the real signal. Searches for "duskmourn commander decks" rose 80% in the past 7 days in Google Trends (US), and the query shows as Breakout over the past month.

Duskmourn Commander decks release date and what is in them

The four decks released with Duskmourn: House of Horror on September 27, 2024, per Wizards' decklist announcement. Each one includes:

  • A ready-to-play 100-card deck with 2 traditional foil borderless commanders (a face commander and a featured commander) and 10 new-to-Magic cards
  • 10 non-foil double-sided tokens
  • 10 Scheme cards for the Archenemy format
  • A deck box, a strategy insert and a Duskmourn Collector Booster Sample Pack

Wizards' editor's note adds that the decks do not include a life wheel.

The four decks and their face commanders, checked on Scryfall:

Deck Colors Face commander
Endless Punishment Black-Red Valgavoth, Harrower of Souls
Miracle Worker White-Blue-Black Aminatou, Veil Piercer
Death Toll Black-Green Winter, Cynical Opportunist
Jump Scare! Green-Blue Zimone, Mystery Unraveler

How much are Duskmourn Commander decks? (MSRP)

There is no official MSRP. Duskmourn launched before Wizards went back to listing suggested prices, which it announced starting with Foundations later in 2024. Retailers set their own prices. At launch, stores such as Moonshot Game Store and Knight and Day Games listed single decks at $44.99 (Moonshot showed a $49.99 regular price), so about $45 a deck is the fair launch number. Four decks at that price come to about $180.

Duskmourn Commander deck eBay prices (sold, November 2026)

We checked eBay sold listings for sealed decks on November 19, 2026:

Deck Sold prices (date)
Endless Punishment $224.95 (Nov 11), $229.99 (Nov 14)
Miracle Worker $66.60 (Nov 16)
Death Toll $41.87 and $56.88 (Nov 4), $55.99 (Nov 7), $59.99 (Oct 27)
Jump Scare! $105.13 (Oct 27)
All four decks, sealed $227.50 (Nov 13), $249.50 (Nov 12), $270 (Nov 15), $288.20 (Nov 5), $313 and $330 (Nov 7 to 8), $399 (Nov 17)

In late October, sealed four-deck sets sold for $312 to $359.99. The four-deck price swings a lot, so look at several sales, not one.

Which Duskmourn Commander deck is worth the most?

Endless Punishment, by a wide margin. Its face commander, Valgavoth, Harrower of Souls, is the most valuable card in the Duskmourn Commander set on Scryfall at about $27.48 for the borderless version, checked today. The other three face commanders (Aminatou, Winter and Zimone) each list under $1 there. A deck that sells for over $200 needs more than one card, so treat Valgavoth as the clearest reason, not the whole reason.

Death Toll is the cheapest. Its sales around $42 to $60 sit near or just above the ~$45 launch price.

How rare are Duskmourn Commander decks?

Wizards does not publish print runs for Commander decks, so no number exists. Two years after release, new sealed copies come mostly from resellers and stores holding old stock, which is why prices now depend on the deck rather than on a list price.

The math after eBay fees

eBay charges 13.25% on Collectible Card Games sales up to $7,500, plus $0.40 per order over $10, per its selling fees page, checked today. Before shipping and tax, using the ~$45 launch price:

  • Endless Punishment at $224.95 nets about $194.74, about $150 over a $44.99 launch cost.
  • Death Toll at $55.99 nets about $48.17, only about $3 over launch cost. At $41.87 it nets $35.92, a loss.
  • Four-deck set at $227.50 nets about $196.96, about $17 over four decks at $44.99 ($179.96). At $399 it nets about $345.73.

If you buy now, you are paying today's eBay prices, not $45, so the same math only works if you expect prices to climb further.

Is the Duskmourn Commander deck worth it?

Only Endless Punishment has clearly gained value: about $225 sealed against a ~$45 launch price. Death Toll trades near launch price ($42 to $60), and Miracle Worker sold at $66.60. Buying a four-deck set today at $228 to $399 mostly buys you one valuable deck and three ordinary ones.

Flip, hold or pass? Our take

This is analysis, not a promise or financial advice.

  • Hold: A sealed Endless Punishment if you own one. It is the deck the market is paying for, and selling into a short search spike is rarely the best timing.
  • Flip: Four-deck sets you already own, if you can sell near the top of the recent range ($330 to $399). At the low end ($227.50), fees and shipping eat most of the gain.
  • Pass: Buying Death Toll or Miracle Worker sealed to resell. Their sold prices sit close to launch price, so there is little room after fees.

For a newer deck with the same story, see our TMNT Turtle Power! Commander deck price breakdown, and our Bloomburrow Commander decks price post for another older set.

More Magic coverage

We follow Commander deck prices, Secret Lair drops and new set releases in our MTG Discord. Browse every Magic: The Gathering article, or read our guide to selling Magic cards.

Magic: The Gathering is a trademark of Wizards of the Coast. Friends & Family is an independent reselling community and is not affiliated with or endorsed by Wizards of the Coast.

Sources

Not ready to join?

Get the free weekly releases email

What dropped, what sold and what's coming next, every Monday. Unsubscribe any time.

Get the Calls Before Everyone Else

Join 2,300+ paying members getting daily flip alerts, restock pings and 1-on-1 help from 20+ expert resellers.

Start Free Trial