
The Taylor Swift "I Knew It, I Knew You" 10-inch vinyl comes in two versions, Jessie's Hat and the star-shaped Jessie's Sheriff Badge, and both cost $24.99 on the Taylor Swift Official Store. They came back for a limit-1-per-customer restock on November 18, 2026 and were sold out again when we checked on November 19, shipping on or about November 29. The store doesn't publish how many were pressed. On eBay, since the restock, single records sold for $79.99 to $110 and the pair for $149 to $189.99 (November 18 to 19), down from a $185 median for the pair earlier in November.
People are searching "taylor swift toy story vinyl", "i knew it i knew you vinyl ebay", "restock" and "sold out". Here's each answer.
What is the Taylor Swift Toy Story vinyl?
It's Taylor Swift's original song for Disney and Pixar's Toy Story 5, "I Knew It, I Knew You", pressed as two 10-inch picture discs. Per the official store:
- Jessie's Hat: a circular picture disc with Jessie's red cowboy hat on one side and the Toy Story 5 logo on the other.
- Jessie's Sheriff Badge: a star-shaped picture disc with "Sheriff" on one side and the Toy Story 5 logo on the other.
Both have the song on Side A and an instrumental on Side B, with collectible cover art. They first went on sale on June 4, 2026 as a short "collector's edition" window that ran until the next afternoon or while supplies lasted, ahead of the movie's June 19 release.
How much is the I Knew It, I Knew You vinyl?
$24.99 each on the Taylor Swift Official Store (store.taylorswift.com), so $49.98 for both before shipping and tax. The November restock was limit 1 per customer and marked final sale: no refunds or exchanges.
Is the Toy Story vinyl sold out? Restock
Yes, both were sold out again on November 19, 2026. The store put both records back up on November 18 (around 4 p.m. ET), a few months after the June window. Restocked orders ship on or about November 29, 2026. The store hasn't said whether more will come, so a second restock is possible but not announced.
How rare is the Taylor Swift Toy Story vinyl?
No pressing number is published. What we know: the first sale ran for about a day in June, the restock was capped at one per customer, and both sold out within a day. Supply isn't tiny, though. We counted more than 100 sold eBay listings since June across the two records, and the restock just added more copies.
I Knew It, I Knew You vinyl eBay prices
We checked eBay sold listings on November 19, 2026, split by version:
- Both records (set): $149 to $189.99 in four sales since the restock (November 18 to 19). Earlier in November the set sold for $165 to $239 (median $185, 9 sales), and before November the median was about $199.
- Jessie's Hat alone: $99 to $110 since the restock (median $105, 3 sales). Earlier in November, median about $100.
- Jessie's Sheriff Badge alone: $79.99 to $99.99 since the restock (3 sales). Before November it sold around $105.
The Hat has held up slightly better than the Badge. Most recent sales are presales, sold before the buyer's restock order has shipped.
The math on a restock pair
Say you got both at $24.99 each and sell them as a set for $150:
- eBay fees at about 13.6%: about $20
- Shipping two 10-inch records: about $8
- You keep about $122, roughly $72 over the $49.98 retail, before the store's shipping and tax.
A single Hat at $105 nets about $85 after fees and about $6 shipping, around $60 over retail. A Badge at $80 nets about $63, around $38 over retail.
Is the Taylor Swift Toy Story vinyl worth it?
Yes, if you paid $24.99: even today's lower sales leave about $38 to $60 per record after fees. Buying one now on eBay to flip is a different story. The pair already slid from a $185 median to about $150 since the restock, and more presale listings will land as November 29 orders ship.
Flip, hold or pass? Our take
- Flip: a restock copy if you want quick profit. List before most orders arrive around November 29.
- Hold: if you're a Swiftie collector. The star-shaped Badge and the Hat are a matched pair tied to a Pixar movie, and sealed pairs could hold up after the holidays if the store doesn't restock again.
- Pass: paying $150+ for a pair to resell. The restock just showed the store can bring them back.
For the rest of Taylor Swift's store this month, see the All Too Well snow globe price, the Red plush cat and ornaments and today's lowkey flips for the cardigan cat pieces. More records are in the vinyl category.
Get the vinyl calls in our Discord
Our vinyl channel posted both restock links the moment they went live, with the price and the limit. See how it works on our vinyl resell group page.
Taylor Swift is a trademark of TAS Rights Management, LLC. Toy Story is a trademark of Disney/Pixar. resell.ing and Friends & Family are not affiliated with or endorsed by Taylor Swift, Disney, Pixar, Walt Disney Records or eBay. Resale estimates are our opinion, not a promise of profit.
Sources
- Taylor Swift Official Store: "I Knew It, I Knew You" 10" Vinyl (Jessie's Hat) and (Jessie's Sheriff Badge) (price, limit, final sale, ship date, sold out; checked November 19, 2026)
- ABC Audio via Lakes Media Network: Taylor Swift offers two unique vinyl versions of new 'Toy Story 5' song (June 4, 2026: both designs, sale window, June ship date)
- WDW News Today: Pre-Order Taylor Swift's 'I Knew It, I Knew You' Collector's Edition Vinyl (June 2026: 24-hour window, Side A / Side B, Toy Story 5 release date)
- eBay sold listings: taylor swift i knew it i knew you vinyl (checked November 19, 2026)
- Google autocomplete and Google Trends, United States, past 7 days and past month (checked November 19, 2026)
Not ready to join?
Get the free weekly releases email
What dropped, what sold and what's coming next, every Monday. Unsubscribe any time.