The Suki Waterhouse Milk Teeth Vertigo Vinyl exclusive was limited to 1,000 hand-numbered copies at $34, and the product page now shows 0 / 1000 left and "Sold out". It's a pre-order that ships December 11, 2026, and presale copies sold on eBay for $84.99 and $85 on October 30 and 31.
Short version: the drop sold through fast, the aftermarket opened at about 2.5x retail, and the only open question is how many buyers will pay that until the record ships.
How much is the Suki Waterhouse Milk Teeth vinyl?
Retail was $34.00 (before tax and shipping) on the official Vertigo Vinyl product page, checked October 31, 2026. The listing describes it as a Black in Blue in Clear vinyl LP with white and red splatter, limited to 1,000 hand-numbered copies, and a pre-order that ships 12/11/26. The page offers a "Notify me" signup if the pressing is restocked or a new run is made.
Milk Teeth is Suki Waterhouse's 2022 Sub Pop EP; the record label on the Vertigo art reads Sub Pop SP 1540 at 45 RPM, with six tracks including "Neon Signs", "Valentine" and "Good Looking".
How rare is it?
1,000 copies, hand-numbered, and the page now reads 0 / 1000 left. Vertigo Vinyl's page says nothing about a repress, only a restock notification, so treat the run as fixed unless the store says otherwise.
What Milk Teeth vinyl sells for on eBay
We checked eBay sold listings for "Suki Waterhouse Milk Teeth vinyl" on October 31, 2026:
- Vertigo Vinyl exclusive /1000 (this pressing): $85.00 (October 30, best offer, plus $5.86 shipping) and $84.99 (October 31, best offer, plus $5.13 shipping). Both were listed as presale, shipping in December.
- Standard blue "Loser Edition" and other blue pressings: about $19 to $22 (September 14 to October 28)
- Signed copy: $224.99 (September 7, best offer accepted)
Two sales is a very thin sample, but both landed within a dollar of each other.
Flip, hold or pass? Our take
Rough math on one copy bought at retail:
- Buy at $34 (before tax and shipping, which we haven't confirmed)
- Sell for $85
- eBay's 13.6% fee plus $0.40: about $11.96
- Shipping an LP: about $5 (our estimate)
- Profit: about $34, or roughly 100% on your cost, before what you paid to ship it to you
Flip: yes, if you have one. A sold-out, hand-numbered 1,000 pressing selling at 2.5x retail is a clean margin, and presale buyers are paying today.
Hold: reasonable for one copy. A signed copy sold for $224.99, so there's collector demand, and prices on sold-out exclusives often drift up around the holidays. The catch is that all you have is two data points.
Pass: if you'd buy at $85. At that price you'd need about $110 just to match the flip profit.
Our call: sell presale if you want the profit locked, keep one if you're a fan. Don't price above the first sales until more show up. This is a market read from the sold listings, not a documented team call.
What could go wrong
- Presale delivery: the record ships December 11. Buyers who pay you now will wait, so ship the day it lands. If it slips, tell them.
- Thin demand data: two sales don't make a price. Listings at $85 and best offer may settle lower.
- Restock risk: Vertigo Vinyl's page offers restock alerts, so supply could grow.
- Not the standard pressing: the common blue Loser Edition sells for around $20, so be sure your listing says "Vertigo Vinyl Exclusive /1000".
More limited pressings are in the vinyl category. See how to sell vinyl on eBay and our GTA VI vinyl restock for how we price presale records. We flag drops like this in our Discord as they go live.
Sources
- Vertigo Vinyl: VV Exclusive Milk Teeth - Suki Waterhouse (price, 1,000-copy limit, sold-out status, ship date, color description)
- eBay sold listings: Suki Waterhouse Milk Teeth vinyl (checked October 31, 2026)