Reality Fracture hit tabletop on October 2, 2026, and the money is concentrated in a very small group of cards. We sorted the whole set by TCGplayer's market price on October 14 and pulled the five at the top.
A few things to know before the list:
- All five are Collector Booster-only foils. Four are Facet Foils and one is a Fracture Foil.
- Prices are TCGplayer market prices, which are built from recent sales and move daily. Each card has a chart below so you can see where the price has been.
- The serialized chase card is covered separately. Bloodline Recollector (/500, per Wizards) has no tracked TCGplayer sales yet, so it can't be ranked this way. See the section near the end.
- Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them, Friends & Family may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Why these five cost so much
Wizards' Collecting Reality Fracture article explains the supply side:
- Facet Foil Shattered Mirror cards appear only in Collector Boosters. There are 13 of them: five rares at about 6,000 copies each and eight mythics at about 3,000 copies each. Each one is in under 1% of Collector Boosters.
- Fracture Foil Japan Showcase cards also come only from Collector Boosters. There are 10 Japan Showcase cards, and the fracture foil version takes 1% of the foil Booster Fun slot.
- A Collector Booster costs $26.99 and a box holds 12, so a box is $323.88 at MSRP. Every card on this list is currently worth more than that box.
Scarcity explains the price level. It doesn't explain whether the price will hold, which is where the charts and the sales data come in.
#5: Craterclaw Colossus (Facet Foil)
Craterclaw Colossus (Borderless) (Facet Foil) is a mythic 5/5 artifact creature that gives your creatures trample and extra power when it enters.
- Market price: $444.89
- Most recent sale: $420.00
- Listed median: $600.00, with 24 copies from 21 sellers
- 3-month sales: 17 sold, highest $700.00
Chart: TCGplayer, captured October 14, 2026.
This one has the steepest climb of the five. The chart shows it sitting near $200 in late September and then jumping to the mid-$400s, a gain TCGplayer's chart labels at about +121% over the window. The gap between the $445 market price and the $600 listed median is also the widest here. Sellers are asking well above where it's actually selling, which usually means patient sellers, not proven demand at that price. (TCGplayer's page also shows a $7.98 low sale in its 3-month snapshot, which looks like an outlier rather than a real Facet Foil sale.)
#4: The Theorist, Jace Beleren (Fracture Foil, Showcase)
The Theorist, Jace Beleren (Showcase) (Fracture Foil) is the odd one out. It's a Japan Showcase fracture foil, not a Facet Foil, and it's a playable planeswalker, so some of the demand comes from players, not only collectors.
- Market price: $467.82
- Most recent sale: $500.00
- Listed median: $592.00, with just 11 copies from 11 sellers
- 3-month sales: 41 sold, between $410.00 and $590.00
Chart: TCGplayer, captured October 14, 2026.
It has the most sales of the group by a wide margin (41), and the volume is rising even as the price slides, from about $570 to about $463 on the chart. That's a healthy pattern: lots of buyers at a falling price is a market finding its level, not a market drying up. The listed supply is thin, only 11 copies.
#3: Darklight Phoenix (Facet Foil)
Darklight Phoenix (Borderless) (Facet Foil) is a mythic 3/2 flying, haste Phoenix that comes back from the graveyard when two or more creatures die in a turn.
- Market price: $486.79
- Most recent sale: $400.00
- Listed median: $445.00, with 36 copies from 30 sellers
- 3-month sales: 21 sold, between $400.00 and $699.99
Chart: TCGplayer, captured October 14, 2026.
Look at the chart's axis before you read the slope: it runs only from about $485 to $525, so the "drop" is small. The more useful signal is the spread between the $487 market price and the $400 most recent sale. The market price is lagging the sales, which tends to point down, not up. Playability helps this card more than most, since it's a recursive threat with a real Modern angle.
#2: Omnipresence (Facet Foil)
Omnipresence (Borderless) (Facet Foil) is a mythic that lets you cast spells without paying their mana cost if they cost less than your creature count.
- Market price: $494.36
- Most recent sale: $330.67
- Listed median: $435.00, with 48 copies from 38 sellers
- 3-month sales: 14 sold, between $330.67 and $1,000.00
Chart: TCGplayer, captured October 14, 2026.
This is the cautionary chart. Early sales were at $1,000, and the price has since fallen by roughly half (TCGplayer labels it about -50%). The most recent sale of $330.67 is a long way under the $494 market price, and it has the most copies listed of any card here (48). It's still #2 on a market-price sort, but the sales say it's heading down. Don't read the ranking as demand.
#1: Hexhaven Invigorator (Facet Foil)
Hexhaven Invigorator (Borderless) (Facet Foil) is a mythic 6/6 vigilance creature that fetches that many lands whenever it's dealt damage.
- Market price: $516.07
- Most recent sale: $465.00
- Listed median: $510.00, with 28 copies from 26 sellers
- 3-month sales: 24 sold, between $464.01 and $850.00
- Lowest listing: $450.00
Chart: TCGplayer, captured October 14, 2026.
This is the tidiest of the five. The listed median ($510) is almost exactly the market price ($516), so sellers' asks and recent sales are close, with the last sale at $465. The chart spiked to about $560 in late September, then settled into the low $500s. It also has the most sales among the Facet Foils here (24). If you were going to hold one Facet Foil, this chart gives you the least to argue with.
The main chase card: Bloodline Recollector
Bloodline Recollector (serialized, double rainbow foil) is the set's headliner and its main chase card. It's serialized to /500, so only 500 copies exist, and per Wizards it shows up in under 1% of Collector Boosters.
Sales haven't settled yet, so there's no reliable market price. TCGplayer's own writeup reported no confirmed TCGplayer sales and said eBay had listings from about $2,500 to $10,000, depending on the serial number. Those are asking prices, not completed sales, and we haven't verified them ourselves. Our expectation is that it settles somewhere in the ~$3,000 to $5,000 range, but that's our estimate, not a market fact, and low serial numbers will likely sell for more. We left it off the ranked list above because there's no sales data to rank it on.
Fee math before you sell
eBay's Collectible Card Games fee is 13.25% of the sale (up to $7,500) plus $0.40 per order over $10 (eBay's fee page, checked October 13). On a $516.07 sale, that's about $68.78 in fees, leaving about $447.29, before shipping and supplies. At these prices, insure and track every sale.
Flip, hold or pass?
This is analysis, not a promise. Every price here is only about two weeks old.
Flip: The cards where listings sit well above recent sales (Craterclaw Colossus at $600 listed vs. $445 market) are the hardest to sell at the asking price. If you pulled a copy and want cash, price near the last sale, not the market price or the median ask.
Hold: Of the five, The Theorist, Jace Beleren and Darklight Phoenix have playable cards behind the price, and Jace has the most trading volume. If you hold anything, it's the ones people also want to play. Holding a Facet Foil is a bet on a short supply (about 3,000 copies per mythic, per Wizards) outlasting the early hype, and the charts show that hype is already fading on at least one card.
Pass: Omnipresence is the one we'd be careful with. Its price has roughly halved since the first sales, its latest sale is far under the market price, and there are more copies listed than any other card here. Buying it because it's #2 on a price list is how people end up holding a falling card.
Pull from a Collector Booster and want to know your odds? Wizards puts each Facet Foil at under 1% of packs, so these are rare, not guaranteed money. A box at MSRP is $323.88, and none of this makes that a sure thing.
Follow Reality Fracture prices with us
Our Magic: The Gathering group tracks Secret Lair drops, new sets and singles as they move. For the sealed side of this set, see our Reality Fracture release day prices, browse more Magic: The Gathering articles, or if you're new to selling, read how to sell Magic cards. You can also browse the full Reality Fracture singles list on TCGplayer.
Magic: The Gathering is a trademark of Wizards of the Coast. Friends & Family is an independent reselling community and is not affiliated with or endorsed by Wizards of the Coast or TCGplayer.
Sources
- TCGplayer — product pages and price charts for Hexhaven Invigorator, Omnipresence, Darklight Phoenix, The Theorist, Jace Beleren and Craterclaw Colossus (all checked October 14, 2026)
- Wizards of the Coast — Collecting Reality Fracture
- TCGplayer — Top 10 Most Expensive Cards From Magic: The Gathering Reality Fracture (October 9, 2026; source for the Bloodline Recollector eBay listing range)
- eBay — Selling fees